Last weekend Holly and I talked about the unfortunate tendency to see things in your own life or in other’s lives (like Indy’s) as a “phase.” The problem with this is the implication that we’re all on a path towards some kind of ideal “self.” And if there is an ideal “you” out there in the future, well, that implies there’s a nice underlying dissatisfaction with current “you.”
In that way, it’s a bit like an “original sin” mindset, except I think we tend to replace “Jesus” with “Self Improvement” as our modern saving grace. No after-life, just a future-life as someone in an idealized personal state. Personally, I like to envision myself balanced like a trapeze artist at the top of
Maslow’s ladder.
Anyway, the Indy/Motherly implications for me are this: If I were to tell people he’s going through a “phase” right now of being (fill in the blank), I am communicating several things:
--My hope (or acknowledgement) that his behavior and current self is temporary.
--My dislike of this behavior I feel is “phase” related.
--My expectation that he will some day move through phrases I comprehend (and he does not) to arrive at a realm of
personhood or behavior that is final and expected.
This is all very socially acceptable when a child is two, but when do parents stop feeling this way? When is a person a “person” – 13? 16? 24? I mean,
isn’t it insulting right now to speak of Indy this way? I
wouldn’t take kindly to my mother letting me know I was in my “young motherhood” phase right now.
So, this came up more specifically because Holly and I were discussing religious feelings from our youth in this manner, and we stopped ourselves to break down why that conversation had problems – listing out our assumptions and generalizations about other people’s experiences, noting the “phase” language and its disrespect, and then just generally wondering when our culture of constant improvement would ease up in our lives and language.
Sorry this was so long. I’m experiencing a rambling phase, and my ideal future self will always post in
scannable bits.